Home 5 Blog Posts 5 How do we help students become critical, but not cynical? 

How do we help students become critical, but not cynical? 

by Against the Grain | Dec 4, 2025 | 0 comments

#

An interview with critical thinking expert, Dr. Tom Chatfield: Part I 

By: Camille Gamboa, Associate Vice President of Corporate Communications, Sage, and Michael Todd, social science communications manager, Sage, and editor of Social Science Space

Dr. Tom Chatfield

Dr. Tom Chatfield is a technology philosopher, author, advisor, and speaker with a deep interest in critical thinking, AI, and future skills. Following the release of his new white paper, “AI and the Future of Pedagogy,” my colleague Michael Todd and I asked him some questions about how libraries and classrooms can help students build critical thinking skills in an AI world. As you’ll see, Tom shared fascinating insights below.

And there’s more. Stay tuned for Part II, where we dive into practical strategies for developing student cognitive skills with the help (and not in spite) of AI.

Camille Gamboa and Michael Todd: First, tell us a little about yourself and your work supporting critical thinking in students?

Tom Chatfield: I write and create books and resources that promote critical thinking. I'm very, very passionate about critical thinking, which I broadly define as having the skills to engage in an evidence-based, rigorous and, hopefully, less deceived way with the wealth of resources that are out there. 

CG and MT: A big part of your work is helping students to understand the biases that exist and identify their own. How can librarians and faculty help students identify, scrutinize, and deal with their own biases? 

TC: In terms of biases, the most important thing for me is that it simply begins with pausing and self-reflection. With the habit of self-reflection comes the realization that you're never going to get over all of your biases, because to be human is to be an individual with a particular, necessarily limited perspective on the world. And that's fine. 

The key is what you do about the vulnerabilities this creates. When you're in a situation where a question is complicated, or morally fraught, or not familiar to you, you need to pause and seek cognitive “reinforcements”: books and media and materials that are reliable, interesting, and trustworthy; or individuals and interactions with individuals that are directed towards understanding and exploration. 

This is the great thing that the library has done. As an institution, it allows us to take a moment and say, "Look, I don't know all these things. There's this area I'm interested in, that's important, and I obviously don't know enough about it. So, I'm going to stop and make a plan for lessening my own kind of ignorance and confusion.” That's the fundamental point I like to make in my books: it’s about having a healthy relationship with your own uncertainty and ignorance. Curiosity is a great starting point and, then alongside this, you can start developing a strategy for lessening uncertainty, engaging in a constructive way with complexity. 

CG and MT: Can you talk about the different kinds of biases that students, and really all individuals, have to deal with?

TC: The word ‘bias’ is often used loosely. Sometimes, we’re fully aware of our biases—like when I say, “I really don’t enjoy working with people who tap their feet; it irritates me.” That’s a conscious bias, a kind of prejudice or predetermined stance. It’s dismissive, yes, but it’s also deliberate.

Then there’s unconscious bias. I might not realize that I treat people who look different from me in ways that aren’t justified. I may be unaware of these patterns, which mostly relate to social and cultural contexts, but once they’re identified, I can hopefully try to mitigate them or learn enough to overcome them. 

Then there’s the broader category of what we call cognitive biases, which are predictable errors of judgement that result from how people tend to think – including some unconscious biases, like stereotyping, but also structural things like confirmation bias. This describes the fact that most of us are prone to paying more attention to information that supports our existing worldview or flatters what we wish were true, rather than maintaining a genuinely open mind.

To some extent, bias is just part of being a conscious individual navigating the world. The mental shortcuts that lead to cognitive biases are fine in many situations: safe, simple, familiar ones. But when things are complex, pressured or unfamiliar, they can be harmful, especially in situations requiring clear judgment. If I’m choosing an insurance provider and I go with the one that has a glossy logo or a salesperson who looks like me or flatters me, that bias could lead me astray—especially if the product is inferior or deceptive.  

In such cases, it’s wise to pause and say, “Hang on, I don’t have enough information to make an informed decision.” That’s when we need to override our gut instincts, do some research, seek advice, and get over ourselves.

If I choose a restaurant because it looks inviting, that might be a perfectly reasonable heuristic: a useful cognitive shortcut. In a sense, a cognitive bias is just a misfiring heuristic. What’s crucial is being alert to when and why our instincts and intuitions might lead us into error—especially when the consequences matter.

CG and MT: What advice can you give to faculty and librarians who are trying to help their students build critical thinking skills?

TC: I would emphasize that students should be encouraged to get comfortable with uncertainty. Sounding supremely confident all the time can set an unrealistic and intimidating standard. In contrast, being open, curious, honest, and willing to admit uncertainty can be far more powerful. Saying, “This is really interesting—I don’t know exactly what’s going on here, but let’s explore it,” models a mindset that invites genuine inquiry. Sharing curiosity and uncertainty isn’t a weakness—it’s a strength.

There’s a fundamental difference between students who feel their job is to sound as confident as possible, and those who come to understand that learning involves developing a constructive relationship with their own doubts. I often encourage students to use phrases like, “I don’t know—what do you think?” or “I don’t know this yet,” as tools to unlock deeper understanding. These kinds of questions—What does it mean to know? How can I find out? What would help me?—are where real learning begins.

Learning starts with a confession of uncertainty, and it continues through a lively curiosity about what it means to know, to reduce uncertainty, and to find evidence. I think it’s important to reflect that mindset in writing, whether in assignments or discussions. It’s about getting comfortable with talking about a range of different views and ideas and being honest about your relationship with them: saying “This person argues this,” or “there’s uncertainty about that,” rather than striving for a definitive answer.

Of course, everyone claims they want to encourage questioning. But, in practice, it can be difficult. That’s where technologies, study groups, and mentorship come in: tools that help people practice questioning, both with peers and instructors. There are vibrant communities of knowledge out there, from social media to discussion forums, where learners can engage, share, and grow.

Ultimately, I think it’s about celebrating curiosity as a core value. Celebrating constructive doubt as an aspiration. And embodying that attitude—in how we learn, explore, and share ideas.

CG and MT: How can libraries help students become curious and skeptical, but not cynical? 

TC: One of the things I really value is celebrating the journey of discovery—and great libraries do this beautifully. In my experience working with students across a range of institutions, I’ve noticed a deep tension. On one hand, there’s the genuine excitement and satisfaction that comes from learning, exploring ideas, and gaining knowledge. On the other, there’s the very real grind: completing assignments, getting decent grades, managing workloads, and simply living life.

I often find myself speaking with students who are stressed and overwhelmed, and I try to encourage them to cut themselves some slack. People can be incredibly harsh on themselves. A reading list can start to feel like a mission they’re failing. An assignment can become a looming, implacable test. They worry they’ll never write the perfect answer, and that no one will ever be satisfied with their work.

So, don’t make the perfect enemy of the good. It’s okay not to be sure. You don’t have to pretend to know everything. Your job isn’t to do a poor imitation of a professor; it’s to be honest. I strongly encourage students to embrace their uncertainties, to be kind to themselves, and to work in ways that genuinely suit them.

I put a lot of emphasis on habits and routines as a way of thinking about this. I’ll say, “Let’s look at your work rhythm. What’s your routine?” Libraries, especially when used intentionally, are incredible tools. If you’re physically attending, they can help you focus, connect with others, access resources, and shut out distractions. They’re spaces that support good habits. And these habits aren’t about relentlessly maximizing your productivity: they’re about creating spaces and times that allow you to make progress on things that matter.

So I ask: how will you use these resources in the context of your life, studies, and routines? What works for you? Where do you want to sit? How will you avoid distractions? Try to carve out a bit of good time each day for focused work. Don’t try to read everything—try to read one thing thoroughly. Have a strategy.

If I were to boil all this down, I’d say, “Pause, prioritize, embrace Imperfection.” Think about what you want to achieve. Cut yourself some slack. Develop a strategy, build habits, and set priorities that work for you. That way, you can engage with your tasks without constantly beating yourself up for not being perfect.

Libraries are such a gift in the 21st century. They’re places that give you permission to focus, to seek knowledge, to pause and reflect. They help you regroup intellectually. So, let yourself enjoy it. Turn off your phone. Carve out a little time. Get lost in some ideas.

CG and MT: Libraries today are a lot more than physical spaces. How do these thoughts apply in a virtual realm? 

TC: It’s interesting to think about how all the praise I give to physical library spaces can apply to their virtual resources. What does it mean to offer someone time and space—virtually—within which they can explore ideas, learn, and develop the habits of a critically engaged learner?

One area I spend time on is helping people reflect on the context in which they’re accessing digital resources. What physical space are they in? What routines are they following? Even when working remotely, it’s important to carve out high-quality time and space for learning—and to be encouraged to reflect on that.

There’s also a simple but powerful principle that applies to all digital services: start with user needs. Be obsessively interested in what people are actually doing in their real, messy, complicated lives. What’s working for them? What isn’t? Look at the data.

If we’re attentive to user needs and genuinely curious about how people are solving problems, we can tap into that potential of the remote resources libraries make available. We can introduce a kind of richness and exploratory, mindful engagement into the digital realm. It’s not just about sitting down and using a tool. It’s about making it part of your life—a powerful context for reflection, learning, collaboration, and mutual support, wherever you are.

CG and MT: How do you encourage that without letting it go too far – without encouraging the so-called impostor syndrome, where people do know something, and they are shy about using what they know, or feel that they're ill equipped to do it, when they might be perfectly equipped. Do you have any tips or heuristics for them? 

TC: As I said before, “Don’t make perfect the enemy of the good,” and I think that idea applies in so many areas of learning and creativity. Sometimes, even when someone has impressive knowledge and competence, they hesitate. They’re not 100 percent certain. They know there’s more they haven’t read, perspectives they haven’t considered, and maybe someone else in the room knows more. That uncertainty can be paralyzing—especially when working on an assignment or trying to come up with a completely original angle or the perfect question.

As someone who also writes fiction and works across different mediums, I’ve learned that the most important thing is simply to start. Get something down. Scribble notes. Draft a first version. Venture a comment. That act of beginning is powerful. But, it also presupposes that you feel able to begin—that you’ve given yourself permission to speak, to make an offering, to say, “This isn’t perfect, but I have something to contribute.”

It helps to be specific. Instead of saying, “I think the answer is X,” try, “I’ve read about this particular phenomenon and, in this paper I found, this idea stood out to me. It seems relevant and important.” That specificity allows you to speak honestly and in detail about what you know and where your understanding comes from—without feeling like you have to sound more confident than you are, or like an impostor who doesn’t have the right to say anything at all.

I’ve personally gotten better at scribbling notes and lowering the barrier to trying. There’s a lovely piece of advice I once heard—possibly from a writer or artist—that says: If you buy a new notebook, the first thing you should do is drop it and stomp on it. The idea is to break the illusion of perfection. If the notebook is pristine and beautiful, you might feel unworthy of it—unworthy of your own stationery, your university, your course, your professors, your colleagues. But if you rough it up a bit, you give yourself permission to scribble, to try, to be imperfect.

I’d lastly add that, while AI can be a wonderful tool for researching and challenging and deepening your thinking, one of the great challenges is that it offers instant, fluent, confident verdicts on anything. And this can drive out curiosity, doubt, uncertainty, double-checking, debate – the slow, vital stuff where you start to feel your way into a subject and do more than output answers on demand. So, don’t pretend you have the perfect answer. Be honest about the fact that you have knowledge, thoughts, and something to offer. That offering is valuable. Start there—and take it forward.

Tom’s new white paper, “AI and the Future of Pedagogy,” explores how education can respond to the rise of AI. It argues that technology should enhance, not undermine, core skills — such as critical thinking — and offers practical guidance for integrating AI into teaching while fostering meaningful, human-centered learning.


Camille Gamboa

Camille Gamboa is Associate Vice President of Corporate Communications at Sage, where she leads a team dedicated to sharing the stories and actions behind the company’s mission, vision, and values. She also oversees Sage’s public affairs and advocacy programs, bringing together voices from across the trans-Atlantic to champion a strong future for social and behavioral science. A regular contributor to the Charleston Hub, she writes on the intersection of research, publishing, and academic librarianship.

Michael Todd

Michael Todd is Sage's social science communications manager and editor of Social Science Space. Before joining Sage, he was a longtime newspaper and magazine reporter and editor.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.